They Grieve, They Wait, They Hope: The Hearts We Overlook
Animals Have Emotional Intelligence? WHAT?!
People have always looked at animals and thought, “Of course they just respond to what’s happening around them. They eat because they’re hungry, they run because they’re scared, and they reproduce because instinct told them to.” But what if things weren’t as simple as that?
Despite the fact that many of us still assume animals to be emotionless, there is an overload of research over the last 40 years that has proved otherwise. While not in the same way that humans express and have emotions, animals possess emotions, and a lot of them. As this post will reveal. The more we research and learn about the animal kingdom, the harder it is to brush off the fact that animals go through these things. Joy, attachment, grief, and distress are just a few.
This goes against the assumption that humans have had for thousands of years: that being able to feel and understand emotions is what sets us apart from the animal kingdom. And it’s because animals don’t speak as we do. They have no voice. They can’t tell us if they’re happy, sad, sick, etc. We have to be observant and learn their body language and what it tells us. Their routines and their interactions. The only way to do that is to be patient and learn. It takes a willingness to accept that each animal is going to be different. Once we start looking, there is so much to see.
The Science Behind Animal Emotions
There are so many ways animals behave that suggest they have emotional and social lives. Rats, for example, have been observed working to free other rats. Elephants stay near the bodies of other deceased elephants. Mothers will carry their dead children until they can process how to let go of them. Dolphins have been seen staying near dead companions or calves. Certainly, these behaviours do not definitively prove that animals humanly experience grief or empathy; they do make it difficult to claim their actions are just instinctual.
Behaviorists have been trying to decipher animal interactions for generations. While I’m not in agreement with animal testing, which is what a lot of these researchers do to figure things out, they have found that animals have complex social and emotional lives. Marc Bekoff, who studies animal emotions and behaviors, argues this and says that they deserve to be taken seriously.
The more research that comes out, the wider this list becomes. Primates can respond to and read facial expressions and body language. Dogs are highly responsive to human emotions and behavior and will pick up on even the subtle changes in our voices and behavior. Fish, even animals that humans probably don’t even think of when discussing emotion, have demonstrated behavioral responses associated with stress and anxiety.
None of this means animals are humans, but that is just as misleading as saying that they don’t feel anything at all.
They experience things differently from us, but that doesn’t mean they're nonexistent.
The Story of Kshamenk
One of the most difficult examples I’ve researched and thought about is Kshamenk. A male orca who has spent decades in captivity at Mundo Marino in Argentina.
He was captured in 1992 when he was 3 years old. We have found that Orcas (their more common, yet misleading name is Killer Whale) are extremely social animals. They are actually dolphins. Therefore, in the wild, they live in family groups, travel together in pods, and keep relationships for years.
Kshamenk’s life has been extremely different, sadly.
He has spent over 40 years in captivity, and when his tankmate, Belen, died in 2000 (only 8 years later), he spent much of his time in captivity without another companion.
A couple of years ago, a 24-hour time-lapse released by the non-profit UrgentSeas showed Kshamenk spending extremely long periods lying around without moving near the gate of his enclosure. This footage brought attention to his living conditions and led to calls from advocates for him to be moved to a sanctuary. His tank is so small he could barely turn around; before he was captured, he was able to move around freely, swimming hundreds of miles a day.
I can’t say that he was lonely, bored, distressed, etc.; you can’t tell that just from footage.
But that doesn’t mean the footage is meaningless. It raises serious questions about what would happen to an extremely social animal when it’s kept in an artificial environment for decades, without even one mate. If animals depend on social relationships, movement, mental and physical stimulation, etc., what does it mean when those things are taken away? How would YOU feel if you were put in solitary confinement for years? No human interaction, no physical or mental stimulation, etc.? What would it mean to you to have those things taken away?
Kshamenk’s story is powerful because we don’t have to know exactly what he is thinking to recognize that his situation deserves consideration. His life also forces us to think about the difference between surviving and thriving. An animal can be physically alive without having the kind of life its species is made to experience.
Emotional Lives are Not Limited To One Species
Kshamenk is only one example. There are fascinating examples of emotional behavior throughout the entire animal kingdom. Cows, for example, form strong bonds with other cows. Researchers found that they have preferred companions and can become distressed when separated. This might sound surprising because cows are viewed as livestock rather than as individuals with social relationships.
Then there are the monkeys. Capuchins became famous in an experiment involving unequal rewards. One monkey got a grape while another one got a cucumber for doing the same thing. The monkey that was given the cucumber was visibly upset and refused the food. This became a well-known example of how animals can respond to what appears to be unfair treatment.
Octopuses are another case. They are known for being smart. They have the ability to problem-solve and learn from their surroundings. Researchers have observed a variety of behaviors that continue to raise questions about what is happening inside their minds.
Birds also surprised scientists. Crows and Ravens are capable of impressive problem-solving and social relationships. Some bird species also were observed gathering around dead members of their group. Scientists continue to debate exactly what these behaviors mean, but they demonstrate that death and social loss can produce noticeable changes in animal behavior.
The important thing is not to give these behaviors the same definition as humans. We shouldn’t look at an elephant beside its dead mate and say “That animal is grieving the way I would.” Instead, we should ask ourselves what the behavior tells us about the animal. That distinction matters. Taking animal emotions seriously doesn’t mean pretending we can read their minds. It means being open, having an open mind to the possibility that there is more happening inside them than what we once believed.
Dogs: The Animals We See Every Day, But Take For Granted
We don’t need to see wild animals or have complicated experiments to see examples of emotional behavior. Sometimes the best examples are the ones we easily miss. Our furry friends.
Dogs have lived next to humans for thousands of years, and their ability to read humans is crazy. They can recognize changes in our voice, facial expressions, body language, and routines. If you’ve ever owned a dog, I’m sure you’ve experienced this firsthand.
If you have a bad day and suddenly your dog is sitting beside you, they sense your emotional change. When you are upset, they seem to know before you’ve even said anything.
Dogs can display changes in behavior after losing their human or animal companion. Some may eat less, sleep more, withdraw from people, or search for the person or animal who is no longer there.
There was a dog in Argentina called Capitan. He slept at his owner’s grave after the man’s death and did that for years. Whether or not Capitan understood death the way we do is impossible to know. But his behavior clearly shows that the loss of his owner changed his behavior and his routine in a significant way. That alone is worth thinking about.
For a more personal example, we had 2 dogs. Bella and Daphne. Bella grew up with Daphne, and Daphne tolerated Bella. 2 years later, Daphne suffered from some health conditions, so we made the decision to put her down. While it was a rough decision, it was what our family needed. We let Bella sniff Daphne's body, and she was there while we buried her. Bella mourned for a while, but she recovered quickly. She was very attached, but we think that because she was there and realized Daphne wasn’t alive, she was able to move on after mourning her. And now she is totally fine. Less than 6 months later.
Therefore, we don’t have to prove that a dog understands death exactly like a person does before we acknowledge that the loss of a familiar companion can affect them emotionally.
Winter’s Story
Not every story focuses on suffering. That’s why I picked Winter.
She was a bottlenose dolphin rescued in 2005. If you’ve ever watched Dolphin Tale, that movie was based on a true story. She was tangled in a crab line, and her injuries were so severe she lost her tail. In the wild, this is devastating. Because it is essential for swimming. Yet Winter survived. With the help of vets, rehab specialists, and prosthetics experts, she was fitted with a custom prosthetic tail. She became famous for that. She died in 2021, yet her story is still inspirational to people long after her rescue. Children, injured vets, and people dealing with different challenges found it inspirational that she was able to adapt.
Her story is different from Kshamenk’s. Putting the two stories next to each other offers an amazing contrast.
Kshamenk’s story raises questions about what happens when a highly social animal is confined. Winter’s story is what happens when humans respond to an animal's needs and give it the opportunity to adapt.
Both stories show us that the way humans care for animals matters. Biblically, we are responsible for them too (Genesis 1:28).
Therefore, Do Animals Have Emotional Intelligence?
This brings us back to the original question. Do animals have emotional intelligence?
If by emotional intelligence we mean the same thing we mean when talking about humans, the answer is complicated. Animals don’t have our language, our cultures, or our ability to explain our thoughts and feelings.
But if by emotional intelligence we mean being able to recognize social and emotional cues, form relationships, respond to others, see changes in emotions, adapt behavior based on social experience, then there is a growing amount of evidence that many animals possess at least some of these abilities.
Maybe the biggest mistake we’ve made is expecting animals to demonstrate their emotions in a way that makes sense to us. A dog doesn’t need to tell us, “I’m worried,” for us to notice that it stays by our side when we’re upset. An elephant doesn’t need to explain what a dead companion means for us to recognize that it behaves differently around the body. An orca doesn’t need to speak for us to have legitimate questions about what isolation for 40 years will do to an animal that is meant to be in social situations.
Animals will continue to communicate differently from us. That doesn’t mean they communicate nothing.
The more we study them, the more we discover that the animal world is far more complicated than the old idea of instinct-driven creatures simply reacting to their surroundings.
They form bonds, they respond to loss, they learn and adapt.
We may never know exactly what it feels like to be an animal, and maybe we don’t need to.
Instead of asking whether animals experience emotions exactly like humans, perhaps we should ask a different question:
What if their emotional lives are real, even when they don’t look exactly like ours?
The answer to that question could change the way we see animals around us.
Because animals don’t have to feel exactly the way we do for their feelings to matter.


Great read and very interesting, thanks for sharing 🤗
ReplyDeleteThank you!! - Charity
DeleteWhat a great article I have to say I agree whole heartedly! Especially about the dogs! Over the years I have witnessed the dogs in my
ReplyDeleteLife in action and in tune to my
Life and emotions .. joyfully playing when I felt joyful or cuddling when I needed companionship! Staying by my side for long months of recovery, animals have a selfless protective side to them as well! There is even a theory about why they follow you
Into the bathroom! Look it up, it’s humorous, if not true:) Thank you for sharing! Well written!